(The following stories appeared
in Jacksonville Today and Shopping Centers Today, respectively
in 1993.)
Retail Profile: Stein Mart
By
Bob Andelman
Hugh Jones, Jr. is always on the lookout for new business.
So when the chairman and chief executive officer of Barnett Bank
of Jacksonville heard that an up-and-coming retail chain would
be relocating its headquarters from Nashville to Jacksonville,
he did a little research on the man running the company.
Learning that Jay Stein, chairman of Stein Mart, grew up in
Greenville, Mississippi, Jones figured he was in luck. Many years
earlier, the banker had spent time in Greenville and knew many
prominent people there. He called Stein, introduced himself,
talked about the bank and then wondered if they might have any
mutual acquaintances.
Joe Smith?
"Dead," Stein said.
Harry Williams?
"Dead," Stein said.
This went on for a while before Stein interrupted.
"I don't think I want to get to know you," Stein
said. "All your friends are dead."
Well, Stein got over his reservations. Not only did he choose
Barnett as his bank, he and Jones became close friends and Jones
put the young merchant on his board of directors. Jay Stein -
by all accounts a warm and likable fellow - made a lot of friends
in the dozen years since he came to town. And Jacksonville, in
turn, has been very good to Stein Mart, one of America's rising
stars in men's and women's apparel.
The last 12 months have been particularly bountiful. Stein
Mart went public in April 1992 at $13 per share; by mid-December,
the price had doubled to $27. The chain opened seven new stores
in 1992 and will open up to 12 more in 1993. And the No. 1 signal
that Stein Mart was a nationwide phenomenon: a favorable feature
story on page one of The Wall Street Journal.
Not that Jacksonville's value-conscious shoppers needed convincing.
The city supports four Stein Mart stores, more than any other
city, with a fifth store possible in the not-too-distant future.
"The St. Johns River creates pockets of demographics,"
Stein Mart President Jack Williams says. "It makes it easy
to create and identify markets. And because we live here, maybe
we're able to size up some opportunities that we may miss elsewhere."
"If we were based in Memphis, there would be four in
Memphis," Jay Stein says. (There are currently three stores
in Memphis.)
Part of the company's secret, as the Journal noted,
is Stein Mart's propensity for hiring women well-connected in
social circles to work one day a week as "boutique ladies."
Rather than working for a living, they do it for fun, to clue
friends in on the latest arrivals and even for the 25 percent
employee discount. Stein Mart gets the benefit of the boutiques
ladies' cachet and wide circle of well-heeled and deep-pocketed
friends who might not otherwise shop at a discount store.
But the real secret is in Stein Mart's selection, value pricing
and tasteful display techniques. The inside of a Stein Mart more
closely resembles a specialty store than a discounter such as
Marshalls or Filene's Basement. Prices are low, but there aren't
15 or 20 copies of the latest design from Chaus or Nesi.
Stein Mart was founded in Greenville, Mississippi in1908 by
Jay's grandfather, XXXXXXX. Before his 10th birthday,
Jay - an only child - was spending every Saturday in the store,
working alongside his parents. "It was truly a family business
and our entire family participated," he says. "My mother
worked for the company until I was born and she's still in the
Greenville store every day. I always knew I was going to be in
the business."
But he wasn't content to step into his father's shoes and
continue business as usual. He had an eye for fashion and trends
that no single store could contain. In 1977, eager to prove his
worth to himself and his old man, Stein moved to Memphis and
opened the first Stein Mart branch store. Two years later he
went into Nashville and hired Jack Williams away from Genesco,
Inc., to captain the business side of the operation.
"I needed someone to take the entrepreneurial ideas I
had and translate them into a workable, viable business plan,"
Stein says of Williams. "I bring a fashion sense, an instinctive
merchandising sense. He has the operational and financial expertise
to bring it all together. We both had the good luck to find each
other."
New stores opened as fast as Stein and Williams could capitalize
them. They entered the emerging big cities of the Southeast -
Birmingham, Charlotte, Jackson, Jacksonville, Little Rock, Charleston
and Raleigh - places where Saks Fifth Avenue and Macy's weren't
ready to go but where the markets were crying out for higher
fashion.
XXXXX Stein reacted to his son's success in "mixed"
ways.
"My father always reinforced what Jack and I were doing,
although he came from a different school than we did and was
more conservative than we were," Stein says. "My father
saw hard times in his life. He didn't want to risk what happened
to so many other companies as they expanded."
The elder Stein believed that to separate himself from his
competition, he had to offer something different. He believed
it was price. "He was one of the original discounters,"
Williams says. But XXXXX and Jay Stein were different
men when it came to stocking their respective stores. What sold
in Greenville wasn't enough for Memphis, Nashville or Jacksonville.
"Jay's taste level was a little higher than that,"
Williams says.
When Stein went to Nashville, his concept was to sell better
merchandise at discount prices. In the early days, he was able
to scramble around New York, convincing people to sell him better
merchandise for his southern outposts. Jay bought the ladies
lines, his wife Cindy chose the gifts, Papa Stein selected the
linens and Williams picked the menswear. They built a reputation
by carrying New York labels that were not yet available in the
South. Up until five years ago, most Stein Mart stores carried
a selection of Saks Fifth Avenue labels.
"That was a minor part of the business, but it helped,"
Williams says. "It was exciting to have Saks merchandise
on sale. You could get a shipment of that, run an ad and pack
the store."
The chain opened seven new stores in 1990, five in '91 and
seven in '92, bring the total number of Stein Marts to 52 in
14 states. And expansion in 1993 could mean as many as 12 new
stores.
"Early in the program, we defined a couple of key ingredients
we needed to be mindful of," Williams says. "We worked
real hard to build an infrastructure - personnel and computers
- that will support what we're doing now and going forward."
Part of their methodology has been to instill an understanding
in assistant store managers of what expansion means to them:
stores of their own. "Our assistant managers are chomping
at the bit to run their own stores," Williams says. Incentives
include generous stock option plans.
"The other major component was capital," Williams
says. "We didn't want to be highly leveraged. We've always
had a pretty conservative balance sheet. At times we've been
criticized for not growing faster. But this is a level we're
comfortable with. And we're less dependent on debt than we ever
were, coming off the public offering."
Why is Stein Mart headquartered in Jacksonville?
"We didn't think we could grow the company from Greenville.
Wal-Mart is the exception rather than the rule to operating in
a small town.We had to move," Stein says. "I had gone
to prep school (The Bolles School, Class of '63) here for two
years. And 25 years ago, this wasn't the town it is today. It
was very backward, very provincial."
But the eighth store Stein Mart opened was in Jacksonville.
Stein and Williams spent a little extra time in the city, assessing
its dramatic evolution in the years since Stein was a schoolboy.
"The first thing I observed was that the lifestyle could
be terrific to raise a family and grow a business," Stein
says. "If you wanted to participate, the city had a lot
of lifestyle options. Not to mention the banking and financial
sectors. Of equal importance, Jack and I determined we, as a
company, could be important to Jacksonville. That some of the
non-business goals we share could make a difference in the arts,
in education, in children's health. We felt we could be a big
company in Jacksonville versus a medium-size company in Nashville."
(One of the lifestyle choices the two friends made was to
buy a boat, which they dubbed "Discount." But they
complained to friends they could never get it to operate as efficiently
as the company.)
Stein and Williams take the concept of corporate citizens
very seriously. Among their many affiliations - the symphony,
museums and other civic associations - Stein is partial to The
Bolles School, from which he graduated in 1963, and Williams
is a charter member of Dreams Come True.
Both men are devoted to children. During the year Williams
served as president of Dreams Come True he doubled the number
of "dreams" provided to ailing area children. And Stein
Mart frequently opens its store to these children for shopping
sprees.
"Jack has a soft spot in his heart for kids," Dreams
Come True board member and Arthur Andersen & Co. managing
partner Travis Storey says. "One of the objectives he set
for DCT was that every child with a life-threatening illness
in our service area would have a dream come true."
As for Stein, one year when he served on the board of directors
of Wolfson Children's Hospital, he noticed an unhappy little
girl in the hospital's hallway. Bending down to talk to her,
he learned that she would be making an unplanned, overnight stay
at the hospital. She was upset because she didn't have her teddy
bear with her. Within 15 minutes, according to legend, a bear
was delivered to the little girl from the nearest Stein Mart.
And by the next day, Stein decided that in the future, every
child staying overnight at Wolfson would receive a free teddy
bear to make their visit a little more bearable. Stein Mart now
donates more than 1,000 bears annually to the hospital; each
one is at least 2-feet tall.
"If you can show Jay the goodness in things, he's generous
to a fault," Hugh Jones Jr. says.
Being successful makes such generosity possible.
"They're great merchants," Service Merchandise chairman
of the board and CEO Raymond Zimmerman says. "They had a
formula and they stuck to it. They didn't try to be everything
to everybody and be something they're not. Plus, Jay and Jack
are the kind of people you want to be friends with and take them
home for dinner."
VERSION 2, SHOPPING CENTERS TODAY:
Stein Mart is one of the South's rising stars in men's and
women's apparel.
The last 12 months have been particularly bountiful. The Jacksonville,
Florida-based chain of 52 stores went public in April 1992 at
$13 per share; by year's end, the price had doubled to $26. Seven
new stores opened in 1992 and up to 12 more are expected in 1993.
And the No. 1 signal that Stein Mart was a nationwide phenomenon:
a favorable feature story on page one of The Wall Street Journal.
"They're great merchants," Service Merchandise chairman
of the board and CEO Raymond Zimmerman says. "And they've
come a long way in the last few years. They had a formula and
they stuck to it. They didn't try to be everything to everybody
and be something they're not. The new stores they're opening
are gorgeous and well-run. Plus, Jay Stein and Jack Williams
are the kind of people you want to be friends with and take them
home for dinner."
Part of the company's secret, as the Journal noted,
is Stein Mart's propensity for hiring women well-connected in
social circles to work one day a week as "boutique ladies."
Rather than working for a living, they do it for fun, to clue
friends in on the latest arrivals and even for the 25 percent
employee discount. Stein Mart gets the benefit of the boutiques
ladies' cachet and wide circle of well-heeled and deep-pocketed
friends who might not otherwise shop at a discount store.
"We get an awful lot of benefit from customers who like
the store and tell their friends," company president and
chief operating officer Jack Williams says. "But we still
think it's important to get our story in the newspaper several
times a week." Stein Mart does most of its fashion advertising
in daily newspapers, utilizing lots of white space; TV and radio
are but a minor part of its overall program.
The real secret is in Stein Mart's selection, value pricing
and tasteful display techniques. The inside of a Stein Mart more
closely resembles a specialty store than a discounter such as
Marshalls or Filene's Basement. Prices are low, but there aren't
15 or 20 copies of the latest designs from Chaus, Evan Piccone,
Polo or Nesi.
"Our mix is department store, similar to what a Burdines
might carry," senior executive vice president and chief
merchandising officer Mason Allen says. Allen came to Stein Mart
six years ago after nearly a decade with Ivey's. "The difference
is, we don't carry the commodities. We carry the cream, not racks
and racks. Except for being off-price, we would be more aligned
with a specialty department store, such as Parisian."
The chain, which successfully tested larger sizes for women
in 1992, will experiment with bigger men's sizes this spring
in 18 stores.
Stein Mart was founded in Greenville, Mississippi in 1908
by chairman of the board Jay Stein's grandfather, Sam. Before
his 10th birthday, Jay - an only child - was spending every Saturday
in the store, working alongside his parents. "It was truly
a family business and our entire family participated," he
says. "My mother worked for the company until I was born
and she's still in the Greenville store every day. I always knew
I was going to be in the business."
But he wasn't content to step into his father's shoes and
continue business as usual. He had a natural eye for fashion
and trends that no single store could contain. In 1977, eager
to prove his worth to himself and his old man, Stein moved to
Memphis and opened the first Stein Mart branch store. Two years
later he went into Nashville and hired Jack Williams away from
Genesco, Inc.'s S.H. Kress division (where he was president),
to captain the business side of the operation.
"I needed someone to take the entrepreneurial ideas I
had and translate them into a workable, viable business plan,"
Stein says of Williams. "I bring a fashion sense, an instinctive
merchandising sense. Jack has the operational and financial expertise
to bring it all together. We both had the good luck to find each
other."
New stores opened as fast as Stein and Williams could capitalize
them. They entered the emerging big cities of the Southeast -
Birmingham, Charlotte, Jackson, Jacksonville, Little Rock, Charleston
and Raleigh - places where Saks Fifth Avenue and Macy's weren't
ready to go but where the markets were crying out for higher
fashion.
Jake Stein reacted to his son's success in "mixed"
ways.
"My father always reinforced what Jack and I were doing,
although he came from a different school than we did and was
more conservative than we were," Stein says. "My father
saw hard times in his life. He didn't want to risk what happened
to so many other companies as they expanded."
The elder Stein believed that to separate himself from his
competition, he had to offer something different. He believed
it was price. "He was one of the original discounters,"
Williams says. But Jake and Jay Stein were different men when
it came to stocking their respective stores. What sold in Greenville
wasn't enough for Memphis, Nashville or Jacksonville. "Jay's
taste level was a little higher than that," Williams says.
When Stein went to Nashville, his concept was to sell better
merchandise at discount prices. In the early days, he was able
to scramble around New York, convincing people to sell him better
merchandise for his southern outposts. Jay bought the ladies
lines, his wife Cindy chose the gifts, Papa Stein selected the
linens and Williams picked the men's wear. They built a reputation
by carrying New York labels that were not yet available in the
South. Up until five years ago, most Stein Mart stores carried
a selection of Saks Fifth Avenue labels.
"That was a minor part of the business, but it helped,"
Williams says. "It was exciting to have Saks merchandise
on sale. You could get a shipment of that, run an ad and pack
the store."
The chain opened seven new stores in 1990, five in '91 and
seven in '92, bringing the total number of Stein Marts to 52
in 14 states. And expansion in 1993 could mean as many as 12
new stores.
"Early in the program, we defined a couple of key ingredients
we needed to be mindful of," Williams says. "We worked
real hard to build an infrastructure - personnel and computers
- that will support what we're doing now and going forward."
Part of their methodology has been to instill an understanding
in assistant store managers of what expansion means to them:
stores of their own. "Our assistant managers are chomping
at the bit to run their own stores," Williams says.
"The other major component was capital," Williams
says. "We didn't want to be highly leveraged. We've always
had a pretty conservative balance sheet. At times we've been
criticized for not growing faster. But this is a level we're
comfortable with. And we're less dependent on debt than we ever
were, coming off the public offering."
Going public was a big cultural change for the chain, although
Stein has been looking towards selling stock since 1981. Williams
say that while Stein Mart has adapted to being publicly-held,
the concept of the stores "hasn't changed one inch. Jay
still goes into the market and spots trends. Jay is a wonderfully
instinctive merchandiser who can spot trends and value."
That view is reiterated by the professionals who do business
with Stein Mart.
Recent expansion targets for Stein Mart have included New
Orleans, the Tampa Bay area (a second store will open in 1993),
Houston and Atlanta. Typical stores are 36,000 square feet. The
chain is comfortable in both build-to-suits and retrofits of
existing space. In fact, the chain's first 11 stores were rehabs.
And of the stores scheduled to open in '93, only Fort Myers,
Florida, is new construction. Houston and Augusta are rehabbed
Service Merchandise locations and the Atlanta site was formerly
a Winn Dixie.
"They're in some of the shopping centers we own,"
Publix Supermarkets real estate manager James Leckey says. "They've
also taken some stores where we've gone dark. And they're in
some of the same centers we're in; they basically go after the
same clientele we do. The only down side is that we have a center
with them in Jacksonville where they drew so many people at Christmas
we didn't have enough parking for our customers."
A typical Stein Mart customer is going to be in the store
several times a month or a week, according to Williams. "They
like to run in and see what's new since their last visit,"
he says. "Where we want to be in a community is in a spot
that is conveniently located to some of the better demographic
areas of a city. Our preference is to be around a grocery that
appeals to an upscale market. Things that pull people in frequently.
We can feed our traffic off to other stores; we want other stores
that can feed off to us."
Williams is disinclined to entertain bids from mall developers.
"We're not mall tenants as a rule," he says, "although
we're in a few. We're (primarily) in strip centers. And we don't
feel power centers are where we need to be."
Shopping center developer Dan DuPree, president of Atlanta-based
Cousins/New Market, has done six deals with Stein Mart, from
Boca Raton to Cincinnati.
"I think they add a phenomenal amount to any center,"
DuPree says. "They have a very clear vision of who their
customer is. They market to a niche we don't think anyone else
serves in a non-mall center. They're a great magnet for soft
goods retailers. Jack and I disagree on where power centers ought
to rank as locations for their stores. I think they're good long-term
moves for them." DuPree must be pretty convincing; five
of his six Stein Mart deals are in power centers. "And they're
as honorable a group as exists in the business today," he
adds. "You can legitimately do business on a handshake with
them and you always get what you bargained for."
"Their word is gold as gold," Leckey confirms. "You
never have to look over your shoulder with them."
DuPree recommends not just Stein and Williams as businessmen
he likes to cut deals with; he also shops in their stores.
"I have never been in one of their stores and not spent
$100," he says.
©2003,
All rights reserved. No portion may be reproduced without the
express written permission of the author.
|