Andelman.com Articles Archive
Rogers Murder Trial Preview"
By Bob Andelman
(Originally published in the Cleveland Plain Dealer,
ST. PETERSBURG, FL. - More than five years after the bodies
of a Willshire, Ohio, woman and her two teen-age daughters were
discovered floating in the waters of Tampa Bay, the man accused
of raping and murdering them will begin on Monday (Sept. 12).
Dairy farmer Joan Rogers, 36, and her daughters, Michelle,
17, and Christe, 14, disappeared on June 1, 1989, while vacationing
in Central Florida. Three days later, their bloated bodies -
bound, gagged and nude from the waist down - were discovered
A frustrating three-year search for clues - including a nationally
broadcast episode of the NBC program Unsolved Mysteries
- failed to turn up a serious suspect until a billboard campaign
showing handwriting found on a travel brochure in the Rogers'
car led detectives to a former Tampa aluminum contractor.
Oba Chandler, 47, who grew up and was raised in Cincinnati,
was arrested on September 24, 1992. He was initially charged
with the rape of a Canadian woman two weeks before the triple-murder,
but shortly thereafter was also charged with three counts of
first degree murder. He plead not guilty to all charges and has
been held without bail ever since.
The trial, which could last as long as five weeks, promises
to be among the most sensational in Central Florida history,
replete with alleged confessions made by Chandler to his oldest
daughter, Kristal Mays, and her husband on a visit to their Cincinnati
home in 1989. Mays later taped telephone conversations Chandler
placed to her from jail in which he denied making any confession
to murder. During one such call, however, Chandler allegedly
offered his daughter $8,000, which she assumed was hush money.
"I'm ashamed to say he's my father," Mays said in
A former Pinellas County Jail cellmate of Chandler's, convicted
bank robber Dennis Rowe, also claims to have heard the murder
suspect brag about raping and murdering the women. Rowe says
Chandler had an accomplice, although the police never charged
a second person. (As a result of being publicly labeled a "jailhouse
snitch" Rowe sued Chandler defense attorney Fred Zinober
for defamation and slander - $2-million worth.)
In all, prosecutors say 14 prisoners, two of Chandler's daughters
and one son-in-law all heard him confess details of the crime.
Another prison inmate, this one a former Allen Correctional
Institute (Lima, Ohio) cellmate of John Rogers - uncle of Michelle
and Christe Rogers - told investigators that Rogers admitted
his own involvement in the homicides. (John Rogers was once charged
with raping Michelle, but the charges were later dropped.) According
to Donald Adkinson, the women were killed because Hal and Joan
Rogers were involved with John in a drug and pornography ring
that operated between Florida and Ohio. The biggest apparent
hole in the story is that John Rogers was in jail at the time
of the murders.
Adkinson's potential testimony was a late development in the
case, announced by Chandler's defense. It caused the prosecution
to ask for a delay in the trial, which was denied. "This
is a jailhouse snitch, a guy sitting in jail trying to get a
deal," Circuit Judge Susan Schaeffer scoffed. "This
is not 'Mr. Credible Guy.' Not an FBI agent."
And when the defense announced on Wednesday (Sept. 7) that
it planned to introduce, among other evidence, a videotape of
John Rogers raping a woman in Ohio, the prosecution asked again
that the trial be delayed so that it could study the new evidence.
The second motion was also denied (Sept. 8).
Meanwhile, five ship-to-shore calls made from Chandler's boat,
Gypsy 1, to his Tampa home in the hours after Joan Rogers
and her daughters disappeared may also play an important part
in the trial. So far, Chandler's wife, Debra, has not revealed
the content of those conversations to prosecutors. The telephone
calls are the only evidence revealed to date which may put Chandler
on his boat when the murders occurred.
She also has been unable to provide him with an alibi for
that night or the night a Canadian woman says Chandler raped
her, also aboard his boat.
Important testimony may also come from Rollins Cooper, a former
subcontractor of Chandler's. Cooper told investigators that on
June 1, 1989, his boss rushed off because "he had a date
with three women." The next day, Chandler explained his
grubby appearance was due to being out on his boat all night.
But Cooper's recollection is called into question by Chandler's
defense attorney, Zinober, who wonders why Cooper didn't remember
the conversations the first three times he was interviewed.
Police initially connected Chandler to the murders by matching
his palm print to one found on a tourist brochure in Joan Rogers'
deserted car. Handwriting analysts also matched the writing on
the brochure to Chandler's writing style.
There are more than 75,000 pages of pretrial documents and
a list of 400 potential witnesses. Only the murder trial of O.J.
Simpson - scheduled to begin a week later - will complete with
the Chandler case for the biggest headlines in the Tampa Bay
Murder is not the only charge against Oba Chandler. When this
trial ends, prosecutors will try him on unrelated charges of
raping a Canadian tourist aboard his boat two weeks before the
disappearance of the Rogers women. The Canadian rape victim and
her girlfriend - who met Chandler but declined an invitation
for a sunset cruise aboard his boat - flew to St. Petersburg
after the man's arrest and positively identified Chandler in
a lineup as the victim's assailant.
And ten days after his arrest on the murder charges, Chandler
was also charged with armed robbery, stemming from the September
11, 1992 robbery of $700,000 worth of jewelry from a man in Pinellas
Park, Florida. He plead no contest to the robbery charges and
was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
Chandler also is awaiting trial on unrelated charges of armed
robbery with a deadly weapon and possession of a firearm by a
convicted felon. That case will be tried in Volusia County (Daytona
Beach), where Chandler and his wife lived at the time of his
The Rogers murders set off one of Florida's most sensational
manhunts five years ago, involving the FBI, Florida Department
of Law Enforcement, the Coast Guard, sheriff's departments in
Hillsborough and Pinellas counties (which ring Tampa Bay) and
the Tampa and St. Petersburg police departments. Because the
women were visiting Florida from a bread-basket of tourism, the
Midwest, the grizzly murders set off more than the usual alarm
bells with state and local officials.
Of course, arresting Chandler hasn't stopped attacks on tourists
in the Sunshine State. In the past year, a German tourist was
brutally shot to death while driving on a Miami highway, and
a British tourist was shot at a Tallahassee rest area.
Chandler's trial will likely only serve to refresh many memories
of the attacks on Florida tourists.
Nothing about the Chandler case has been simple for law enforcement
authorities. After pretrial hearings in Pinellas County and spending
many months in the Pinellas County Jail, Chandler was told that
because the murders occurred in the waters of Tampa Bay, jurisdiction
was shared by Hillsborough County (which includes Tampa) and
Pinellas (St. Petersburg/Clearwater). He was given the opportunity
to choose between them and picked Hillsborough, where he was
transferred. But once there, Chandler complained of being held
in solitary confinement in shackles and asked for jurisdiction
- and himself - to be returned to Pinellas. Eventually, his wish
was accommodated. (He may have learned, as Judge Schaeffer pointed
out in court, that Hillsborough juries send more defendants to
death row than Pinellas juries.)
Lead defense attorney Zinober, meanwhile, attempted to force
a change of venue in the case due to extreme pretrial publicity.
He cited 170 articles related to the murders in the St. Petersburg
Times and Tampa Tribune, as well as reports on syndicated
tabloid TV shows such as Hard Copy and Inside Edition.
Zinober also said that in pretrial testimony, Chandler's own
sister, Lula Harris, believed Chandler was guilty based on press
Judge Schaeffer rejected Zinober's motion but agreed to select
jurors in Orlando, 90 miles west of St. Petersburg. On Monday
(Sept. 12), interviews will begin from a pool of 500 potential
jurors. When 14 jurors are selected (12 jurors and two alternates),
they will be given a day to organize their affairs before being
transported to St. Petersburg and sequestered.
Opening arguments are expected to begin by Thursday (Sept.
15). Judge Schaeffer has set aside five weeks on her calendar
for the trial.
All rights reserved. No portion may be reproduced without the
express written permission of the author.